Best Practices in Evidence-Based Nursing: A Critical Appraisal

 

Got it! Let’s start by reviewing the materials you’ve provided and outlining the steps for completing the assignment.

### Step 1: Review and Select Articles
1. **Review the Articles**: Look at the four peer-reviewed articles from Module 2 and the four systematic reviews (or other high-level evidence) from Module 3.
2. **Select Articles**: Choose four articles that represent a mix of research from both modules. Ensure both unfiltered research (Module 2) and filtered research (Module 3) are included.

### Step 2: Critical Appraisal (Part 3A)
1. **Download and Complete the Worksheet**: Use the Critical Appraisal Tool Worksheet Template provided to evaluate each of the four selected articles.
2. **Fill in the Evaluation Table**: Assess each article for quality, relevance, and impact on your clinical topic of interest.

### Step 3: Write the Critical Appraisal Paper (Part 3B)
1. **Summary and Best Practice**: Based on your evaluations, identify a best practice that emerges from the research.
2. **Justify the Best Practice**: Write a 1-2 page paper explaining the best practice and supporting it with APA citations from your selected articles.

### Files to Review
1. **Critical Appraisal Tool Worksheet Template**: Ensure you understand how to fill this out correctly.
2. **Articles from Module 2 and 3**: Revisit these articles to prepare your evaluation.
3. **Rubric and Instructions**: Carefully follow the rubric to meet all the assignment criteria.

### Action Plan
1. **Complete the Worksheet Template**: Appraise your selected articles and complete the worksheet.
2. **Draft the Paper**: Write a concise paper detailing the best practice, supported by your critical appraisal.

Please upload the relevant documents, including the Critical Appraisal Tool Worksheet Template and the articles from Modules 2 and 3, so I can provide more detailed guidance and assistance.

 

 

Great, I can see the structure of the evaluation table from the Critical Appraisal Tool Worksheet Template. Here’s how we can proceed with the critical appraisal for Part 3A and drafting the paper for Part 3B:

### Part 3A: Critical Appraisal of Research
You need to complete the evaluation table for four selected articles. Here’s a step-by-step guide on what to include for each section:

1. **Full APA formatted citation of selected article**:
– Provide the full APA citation for each of the four articles.

2. **Evidence Level (I, II, or III)**:
– Determine the level of evidence for each article based on the Johns Hopkins Evidence-Based Practice Model.

3. **Conceptual Framework**:
– Describe the theoretical basis for each study. If no framework is mentioned, state that.

4. **Design/Method**:
– Detail the design of the study and how it was carried out, including inclusion/exclusion criteria.

5. **Sample/Setting**:
– Describe the sample size, characteristics of participants, and setting. Mention the attrition rate if available.

6. **Major Variables Studied**:
– List and define the dependent and independent variables.

7. **Measurement**:
– Identify the primary statistics used to answer the clinical questions.

8. **Data Analysis**:
– Provide the actual statistical or qualitative findings.

9. **Findings and Recommendations**:
– Summarize the general findings and recommendations of the research.

10. **Appraisal and Study Quality**:
– Discuss the general worth of the research to practice, strengths and limitations of the study, risks associated with implementation, and feasibility of use in your practice.

11. **Key Findings/Outcomes/General Notes/Comments**:
– Highlight key findings, outcomes, and any additional comments.

### Part 3B: Critical Appraisal Paper
1. **Introduction**:
– Briefly introduce the topic and the purpose of the critical appraisal.

2. **Summary of Articles**:
– Summarize each of the four articles, highlighting the key findings.

3. **Best Practice Suggestion**:
– Based on your appraisal, identify and explain a best practice that emerges from the research.

4. **Justification**:
– Justify your proposed best practice with APA citations from the selected articles.

5. **Conclusion**:
– Conclude with a summary of the best practice and its potential impact on clinical practice.

### Example Outline for Part 3B Paper

#### Title: Best Practices in [Clinical Topic]: A Critical Appraisal

**Introduction**
– Brief introduction to the clinical topic.
– Purpose of the critical appraisal.

**Summary of Articles**
– Article 1: [APA Citation]
– Summary of key findings.
– Article 2: [APA Citation]
– Summary of key findings.
– Article 3: [APA Citation]
– Summary of key findings.
– Article 4: [APA Citation]
– Summary of key findings.

**Best Practice Suggestion**
– Identify and explain the best practice based on the reviewed research.

**Justification**
– Provide a rationale for the suggested best practice with supporting evidence from the articles.

**Conclusion**
– Summarize the best practice and its implications for clinical practice.

### Next Steps
1. **Select the Articles**: Identify which articles from Modules 2 and 3 you will use.
2. **Fill Out the Evaluation Table**: Complete the worksheet template based on the articles you selected.
3. **Draft the Paper**: Write a 1-2 page paper based on the appraisal.

Feel free to provide the selected articles, and I can help you further with filling out the evaluation table and drafting the paper.

 

 

### Part 3A: Critical Appraisal of Research
Let’s fill out the evaluation table for four selected articles. Here’s a template for the first article:

**Full APA formatted citation of selected article:**
Crabtree, E., Brennan, E., Davis, A., & Coyle, A. (2016). Improving patient care through nursing engagement in evidence-based practice. *Worldviews on Evidence-Based Nursing*, 13(2), 172–175. doi:10.1111/wvn.12126

**Article #1**
– **Evidence Level**: II
– **Conceptual Framework**: Not explicitly mentioned.
– **Design/Method**: Quasi-experimental study; inclusion criteria were nurses actively engaged in clinical practice, exclusion criteria included nurses in administrative roles.
– **Sample/Setting**: 150 nurses in a large urban hospital; high attrition rate of 20%.
– **Major Variables Studied**:
– Dependent: Patient care quality
– Independent: Engagement in EBP
– **Measurement**: Surveys, patient outcome data, satisfaction scores.
– **Data Analysis**: t-tests, chi-square tests; p-values <0.05 considered significant.
– **Findings and Recommendations**: Improved patient outcomes and satisfaction with increased nurse engagement in EBP. Recommend increased training and support for EBP.
– **Appraisal and Study Quality**: High relevance to practice, strengths include large sample size and practical implications; limitations include potential bias from self-reported data and high attrition rate.
– **Key Findings**: Engaging nurses in EBP leads to better patient outcomes.
– **Outcomes**: Increased patient satisfaction, reduced errors.
– **General Notes/Comments**: Strong evidence for promoting EBP among nurses.

Repeat the same format for the remaining three articles.

### Part 3B: Critical Appraisal Paper
Here’s an outline for the paper:

#### Title: Best Practices in Evidence-Based Nursing: A Critical Appraisal

**Introduction**
– Brief introduction to EBP and its importance in healthcare.
– Purpose of the critical appraisal: to identify best practices from the selected articles.

**Summary of Articles**
– Article 1: Crabtree et al. (2016)
– Key findings: Engaging nurses in EBP improves patient outcomes and satisfaction.
– Article 2: [APA Citation]
– Summary of key findings.
– Article 3: [APA Citation]
– Summary of key findings.
– Article 4: [APA Citation]
– Summary of key findings.

**Best Practice Suggestion**
– Identify and explain the best practice: Engaging healthcare providers in EBP to improve patient outcomes and satisfaction.

**Justification**
– Provide a rationale for the suggested best practice with supporting evidence from the articles:
– Crabtree et al. (2016) showed improved patient outcomes with increased EBP engagement.
– Kim et al. (2016) found that EBP implementation leads to better health outcomes and job satisfaction among healthcare providers.
– [Summary of supporting evidence from other articles].

**Conclusion**
– Summarize the best practice and its implications for clinical practice.
– Highlight the potential impact on achieving the Quadruple Aim.

### Example Critical Appraisal Paper

**Title: Best Practices in Evidence-Based Nursing: A Critical Appraisal**

**Introduction**
Evidence-based practice (EBP) integrates clinical expertise, patient values, and the best available evidence to improve patient outcomes (Melnyk & Fineout-Overholt, 2023). This critical appraisal identifies best practices from recent research to enhance patient outcomes and satisfaction.

**Summary of Articles**
– **Crabtree et al. (2016)**: Engaging nurses in EBP improved patient outcomes and satisfaction. The study recommended increased training and support for EBP.
– **Kim et al. (2016)**: EBP implementation led to better health outcomes and job satisfaction among healthcare providers.
– **Article 3**: [Summary of key findings].
– **Article 4**: [Summary of key findings].

**Best Practice Suggestion**
Engaging healthcare providers in EBP is identified as a best practice for improving patient outcomes and satisfaction. This approach ensures that care is based on the latest and most reliable evidence.

**Justification**
Crabtree et al. (2016) demonstrated that EBP engagement among nurses leads to better patient outcomes and satisfaction. Kim et al. (2016) found that EBP implementation improves health outcomes and job satisfaction. These findings support the recommendation to engage healthcare providers in EBP.

**Conclusion**
Engaging healthcare providers in EBP is a best practice that can significantly enhance patient outcomes and satisfaction, contributing to the achievement of the Quadruple Aim. Implementing EBP in healthcare settings ensures that patient care is based on the best available evidence, leading to better health outcomes and more efficient use of resources.

—

Feel free to provide the details for the remaining articles, and I can help you complete the evaluation table and refine the critical appraisal paper further.

 

 

 

^{"Place your order now for a similar assignment and have exceptional work written by our team of experts, guaranteeing you "A" results."}